Bake Potatoes

How Long To Bake Potatoes at 375 in Foil (Complete Guide)

Baked potatoes are delicious and one of the best comfort foods you can enjoy. And they are very easy to make, so you will not need to be an experienced chef for such a recipe. 

It will take you between 50 and 60 minutes to make some tasty baked potatoes, and you will only need ingredients that you most likely already have in your kitchen. Learn everything you need to know about baked potatoes in this complex guide. 

How long does it take for a baked potato at 375?

If you want to make baked potatoes, you must let them cook for about one hour. But it will also make a difference if you do not bake your potatoes in foil. Baking potatoes in foil takes a bit longer than baking them without. 

You can expect to add five to ten minutes to the baking time if you wrap the potatoes in foil. The exact time will also depend on the size of your potatoes, as smaller pieces of potatoes will bake faster than thick, large potatoes. 


Does it take longer to bake potatoes in foil?

A misconception says that if you bake potatoes in foil, they will need to stay less in the oven. The fact is that the foil will not help the potatoes bake any faster, so they will most likely take the same time to get done. 

Contrary to this belief, when you wrap your potatoes in foil, they might need a few more minutes to bake. This happens because the foil will have to get heated first, and your potatoes will not be exposed to direct heat. 

Also check: How Long to Cook a 1 Pound Meatloaf

So, many people prefer to bake the potatoes without the foil because they get done slightly faster. Plus, you save energy, too, since you will not have your oven on for more than you need to get some delicious baked potatoes.

But ultimately, it is your choice how you bake the potatoes, and it depends on the final result you want to achieve. 

Baking potatoes in foil will give them a softer texture on the surface because they will not get the crispy skin they achieve when you bake them without the foil.

Also, the foil will retain moisture, making your potatoes softer inside and with the texture of boiled potatoes. If this is the dish you want to obtain, wrapping your potatoes in aluminum foil will be a better option.

But if you like the crispy, slightly dry skin of baked potatoes, you want to skip the foil and let them get in direct contact with the heat. 

Note also that when you use foil, seasonings tend to penetrate the potatoes more than when you don’t wrap them in foil.

Due to the extra moisture, the potatoes will get softer, allowing the seasonings you add to them to find a way more profound into the vegetables.

When you bake the potatoes without foil, in most cases, the herbs and other seasonings form a firmer crust skin on the surface of the potatoes without penetrating them too deep inside. 

Also check: How Long To Cook Country Style Ribs In Oven At 350

How long does it take to bake a potato at 400?

If you increase the temperature, your potatoes’ overall baking time will also reduce to 45 to 50 minutes. But know that high baking temperatures could also lead to burned spots on your potatoes and an uneven cooking result.

So, unless you are in a big hurry, you want to give your potatoes time to cook slowly and thoroughly so they have the same texture and uniform color. 

On the other hand, if you like slightly burned potatoes, you can try baking them at a temperature of 400 degrees F for 50 minutes.

They will turn a darker shade of brown and possibly be crispier on the surface. The crispy skin will be even better if you leave your potatoes with the peel on and don’t wrap them in foil.

As a thumb rule, when you decide to wrap your potatoes in foil, you want to peel them first because the skin will only turn soft and mushy during the cooking process. 

Should you bake a potato in aluminum foil?

The opinions regarding using foil or not for baked potatoes are split. Some chefs recommend wrapping the potatoes in foil, while others claim you don’t need to do that at all to get delicious baked potatoes. 

Ultimately, the way you like your potatoes to taste will determine if you need to wrap them in foil. If you want the potatoes to resemble the taste and texture of boiled potatoes and absorb the seasonings better, you want to consider wrapping them in aluminum foil. 

However, if you don’t want your potatoes to have the softness of boiled potatoes, you want to skip the aluminum foil so they get the crispiness and texture that direct heat can give them.

Also, by not wrapping your potatoes in foil, you reduce the moisture level in the oven and allow them to get slightly drier as they get cooked. 

If the cooking time and the energy spent during the cooking process are important factors, then baking your potatoes without foil will also be a better option. By doing so, you will reduce the overall baking time and save energy as a result. 

More: How Long To Cook Homemade Pizza at 350

How Do You Tell If Potatoes Are Undercooked?

Knowing when your potatoes are done is essential for a successful dish. Luckily there are ways to check if your potatoes are well done, so you will not have to guess. 

Use the fork test

Checking your potatoes with the fork is the best way to see if they are cooked all through. All you have to do is stick the fork in the potato and notice how smoothly it goes in. If your potato is well-cooked, the fork will get into it smoothly. However, if they need more time in the oven, you will not be able to penetrate them with the fork. 

You want to use something other than a knife to check if your potatoes are well-cooked, though. Blades are sharp and can fill you since they get easier into many types of foods, even when they are not cooked all the way through. 

Check the time

Note when you put your potatoes in the oven and track the time correctly. If you set up the oven heat right and you pull the potatoes out after one hour, chances are that they will be done. 

It is recommended to use the fork test before you decide whether the potatoes are done. Checking your potatoes with the fork is essential, especially if you are baking thick potatoes because they cook harder. 

How long does it take to grill potatoes at 375?

Grilling your potatoes at 375 degrees should also take between 50 minutes and one hour. You want to grill baked potatoes between 375 degrees F and 450 degrees F. The time the potatoes need to get cooked will also decrease as you increase the temperature. 

Also, you want to avoid grilling potatoes with foil as they will get mushy. This is even more important if you grill thinner slices of potatoes and don’t want them to fall apart when you serve them. 

The cooking time will be split in two. You will have to grill the potatoes for 30 minutes on one side and then flip them on the other. Give them 20 to 30 minutes to cook on the other side before turning the heat off. 

How long does a potato take to bake at 350?

Just like potatoes baked at a higher temperature will get done faster, the ones baked at a lower temperature will require more time to get done.

Baking your potatoes at 350 degrees will need between 60 and 75 minutes in the oven to get cooked through. 

You want the internal temperature of the potatoes to get between 205 degrees F to 212 degrees F to be sure they are done. Like when you bake potatoes at higher temperatures, their size will mature.

So, pay attention to larger potatoes as they might require an extra five to ten minutes to cook, especially at a lower temperature of 350 degrees F. 

Can I bake the potato at 375?

Baking potatoes at 375 degrees F is one of the best temperatures to ensure you have tasty and perfectly cooked potatoes. Ideally, you want to bake potatoes at either 375 degrees F or 400 degrees F. 

Any temperature higher than 400 degrees F will increase the risk of having burned potatoes or potatoes that are burned on the surface but remain relatively uncooked in the middle. This risk is significantly higher for thick potatoes that are one pound or more prominent. At the same time, choosing to bake the potatoes at a temperature of 350 degrees F means that you will spend more energy as they will take more time to cook. 

Can you eat undercooked potatoes?

Potatoes that are raw or not cooked all the way are not safe to eat. Uncooked potatoes contain lectins as well as solanine. These components can cause indigestion and gastric problems, and you could get sick. Also, the starch inside raw potatoes is not easy to digest, and it is better to avoid it. 

However, only some have such reactions, especially if you don’t eat the potatoes raw. Undercooked potatoes might give you digestive issues, though, so it is essential to check how well they are done before serving them. 

When it comes to taste differences, you will notice relatively fast that undercooked potatoes are less tasty and pleasant than those well-done. So, even if they don’t get you sick, you might still not like them. 

What type of potatoes to use for baking

You can use any potatoes for baking, but some taste better than others, depending on how sweet they are. The texture could also differ depending on how fluffy they are. Russet potatoes seem ideal for crispy baked potatoes, which many chefs worldwide prefer. 

Idaho potatoes are just as good for baking as they have a starchy texture and tend to be extremely tasty. 

You can also use waxy potatoes, as they are perfect for baking because they keep their shape when cooked. 

All-purpose potatoes with a reduced level of starch might not be ideal for baking, but they will still give you a tasty dish. 

Feel free to use any potatoes but if you want perfectly baked potatoes, choose ones that are high in starch and have a thick skin. Potatoes are appreciated for their reasonably neutral flavor so they will taste mostly as the seasonings you add to them. 

Best baked potatoes recipe

The best-baked potatoes will have a crispy skin and a fluffy texture inside, and they will be rich in delicious flavors. But how do you prepare such a dish and amaze your loved ones and friends? Here is the best recipe and everything you need to know to get perfectly baked potatoes! 


The best potatoes for baking this recipe would be Russet potatoes. While you can use any potatoes for baking, this strain tends to be the tastiest and has the best texture for such a dish.

It is even more critical to choose Russet potatoes if you want to bake them without foil, so you get the crispy skin that is so tasty! Russet potatoes have thicker skin than other types of potatoes and are ideal for baking. They have a fluffy inside and a sweetness that will mix great with your chosen seasonings. 

Olive oil or butter are also the main ingredients in such a recipe. The best type of fat to use is butter because it adds an exciting flavor to your potatoes. But you can also use olive oil or even avocado oil. 

Salt will add the crunchiness you want to your potatoes, and Kosher salt is the best type to use. You can find it easily in stores, and you might already have it in your kitchen. 

Black pepper that is freshly ground will be the final touch to a delicious dish of baked potatoes. There is a significant difference between pepper and freshly ground pepper. When you ground the pepper on the spot, the taste, smell, and overall flavor it gives to your dish will be much more intense. 

Cooking steps

Before anything else, it is essential to preheat the oven. You can choose the standard temperature of 375 degrees F, but you can also use a higher temperature. Note that if you choose a higher temperature, you will have to reduce the cooking time so you don’t overcook your potatoes. 

1. Use baking paper

To avoid burning your potatoes, it is essential to use baking paper. You can add the baking sheet to the tray that you will use to bake your potatoes or directly on the oven rack. Baking paper will prevent the potatoes from getting burned on the bottom where their skin touches the tray or the rack used. 

2. Prepare your potatoes

Potatoes risk exploding in the oven, but you can avoid such an unpleasant occurrence by poking them with a fork. Make sure to poke them on all sides. You don’t have to poke them a lot, though, as two pokes per side should be enough. 

3. Bake the potatoes unseasoned 

The first baking session should be with the potatoes unseasoned. Put them in the oven and let them bake for 30 minutes. During this time, don’t flip them or open the oven door. 

4. Season your potatoes

After half an hour passes, take the potatoes out of the oven and brush them with olive oil or butter. Make sure to use the pastry brush to cover the potatoes’ surfaces with the oil or butter. Once the potatoes are all the way oiled, add salt in a generous pinch to touch all the parts of the potatoes. Sprinkle the freshly ground pepper on them now as well. 

5. Second baking session

Flip the potatoes on the other side before you place them back in the oven. Give them another 20 to 30 minutes to bake before you check if they are cooked. 

Extra tips: Feel free to add any additional herbs you like to your potatoes. But remember that seasonings should be added after the first baking session so they don’t overcook and flavor your potatoes the right way. 

Final thoughts 

Follow the tips in this guide, and you will have the best-baked potatoes for you and your family. Such a dish could be enjoyed by itself, or you can pair it with your favorite steak or vegetable.

And make sure to add some topping sauce such as a cheese sauce or tomato sauce for an even better meal combination! Baked potatoes are versatile and can be enjoyed at any meal and even as a more consistent snack.

With such a dish, you can’t fail, and everyone will love it! The best way to enjoy your baked potatoes is freshly out of the oven though, so, don’t wait too long to serve them!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *